Overview
Ophthalmic
pathology has greatly advanced the ophthalmologist’s understanding
of the origin, diagnosis, treatment, and prognosis of diseases of the
eye and its adnexa, since the integration of this discipline into
residency training approximately a century ago. The International
Council of Ophthalmology emphasizes the continued importance of
ophthalmic pathology to training of ophthalmologists. It
distinguishes ophthalmology as a medical specialty, which is based on
the understanding of the pathological basis of eye diseases.
Ophthalmic surgery can be regarded as applied ophthalmic pathology.
The major contributions of ophthalmic pathology are of particular
interest to ophthalmology.
All
residents should be engaged with an ophthalmic pathologist who
ideally practices within or with appointment to the ophthalmology
department and who can practice either ophthalmology or pathology in
addition to providing the ophthalmic pathology service.
At
least one residency program in each country should aim to maintain an
ophthalmic pathology laboratory or be affiliated with an ophthalmic
pathology laboratory, which permits ophthalmology residents with a
special interest in ophthalmic pathology opportunity to participate
in grossing, sectioning, and processing of specimens, as well as
related research. Other programs should aim to collaborate with the
national or regional ophthalmic pathology laboratory, or with an
extramural pathologist who works with the faculty and staff in the
ophthalmology department, to develop expertise in ophthalmic
pathology. Residents should have access to ophthalmic pathology
workshops or teleconferences to complete the curriculum requirements.
Standard
Level Goals
The
principal aim is to link ophthalmic pathology with specific
patient-based areas of residency training (eg, oculoplastics, cornea,
glaucoma, retina, ophthalmic oncology). The subspecialties emphasized
should vary according to the prevalence of ophthalmic disease and the
particular expertise of the ophthalmology department and associated
ophthalmic pathology laboratory.
Teaching
can be conducted through regular face-to-face consultation sessions
or clinicopathologic conferences. During their training, residents
should get a minimum of 36 hours (ie, 1 hour per month) of experience
in evaluating pathological specimens with a specialist who has
expertise in ophthalmic pathology.
Teaching
clinicopathologic correlations can be supplemented with
demonstrations through advanced imaging techniques (eg,
ultrasonography, optical coherence tomography, magnetic resonance
imaging), which produce images that are similar to gross pathologic
specimens and histopathologic sections and have the ability to
differentiate pathologic processes.
Advanced
Level Goals
Chairs
in ophthalmology should provide residents with a special interest in
ophthalmic pathology the opportunity to participate in grossing,
sectioning, processing, and examination of specimens.
Very Advanced Level Goals
Chairs
in both ophthalmology and pathology need to identify promising
residents to receive special training and to work with the clinical
faculty and laboratory staff to develop subspecialty expertise in
ophthalmic pathology.
*
* *
Basic Level Goals: Year 1
These goals are pertinent from the beginning of ophthalmology residency and should typically be acquired during the first year of ophthalmic residency training.
A. Cognitive Skills
1. Describe the professional duties and specific and unique aspects of professionalism of ophthalmic pathology, and the significance of ophthalmic pathology to the practice of ophthalmology.**
2. Describe
basic ocular anatomy and histology of the major structures of the eye
and its adnexa:
a. Conjunctiva**
b. Cornea**
c. Sclera**
d. Anterior
chamber**
e. Posterior
chamber**
f. Iris**
g. Ciliary
body**
h. Lens**
i. Vitreous**
j. Retina
and retinal pigment epithelium**
k. Choroid**
l. Optic
nerve**
m. Visual
pathway**
n. Eyelids**
o. Extraocular
muscles**
p. Lacrimal
system**
q. Orbit**
3. Describe
basic pathophysiology of the common disease processes of the eye and
its adnexa, and identify the major histologic findings:
a. Degeneration
(eg, pterygium, keratoconus)**
b. Dystrophy
(eg, Fuchs dystrophy, TGFBI-associated dystrophies)**
c. Infection
(eg, fungal keratitis, bacterial endophthalmitis)**
d. Inflammation
(eg, chalazion, idiopathic orbital inflammation)**
e. Neoplasm
and proliferation (eg, basal and squamous cell carcinoma, uveal
melanoma, retinoblastoma)**
4. Describe
common methods of specimen acquisition and handling for ophthalmic
pathology, especially handling methods that avoid artifacts and
ensure representative sampling:
a. Surgical
biopsy, with special emphasis on the eyelids and conjunctiva, cornea,
and vitreous**
b. Resection
margin marking**
c. Enucleation**
d. Exenteration**
e. Impression
cytology
f. Fine
needle aspiration biopsy
5. Describe
basic information necessary to communicate to the ophthalmic
pathologist regarding study of these specimens.**
6. Describe
common indications for frozen sections in ophthalmic pathology (eg,
complete resection margins in basal and squamous cell carcinoma,
demonstration of lipid in sebaceous gland carcinoma).**
7. Describe
basic steps in handling and processing of gross specimens in the
ophthalmic pathology laboratory through a site visit, with relevance
to ophthalmic surgery.
B. Technical/Surgical Skills
1. Process
specimens for submitting to an ophthalmic pathology laboratory, and
write the accompanying letter to the ophthalmic pathologist (eg,
surgical biopsy, corneal button, enucleated eye, exenteration
specimen).**
2.
Read and interpret reports from these specimens written by the
ophthalmic pathologist.**
3. Participate
as an observer through a site visit in the macroscopic and
microscopic examination of ophthalmic pathology specimens from active
cases.
Standard Level Goals: Year 2 and Year 3
These
goals relate to the second and third years of ophthalmic residency
training.
A. Cognitive Skills
1. Describe
more advanced ocular anatomy (eg, common variants), and identify the
histology of the major structures of the eye and its adnexa relevant
to specific clinical rotation(s) (eg, oculoplastics, cornea,
glaucoma, retina, ophthalmic oncology).**
2. Describe
the pathophysiology and identify the major histologic findings of
common diseases of the eye (eg, keratitis, exfoliation syndrome,
corneal and retinal dystrophies and degenerations, frequent
neoplasms) relevant to specific clinical rotation(s) (eg,
oculoplastics, cornea, glaucoma, retina, ophthalmic oncology).**
3. Describe
the pathophysiology and histology of potentially vision or
life-threatening diseases (eg, temporal arteritis, endophthalmitis,
retinoblastoma, ocular melanoma, extraocular or orbital spread of an
intraocular or periorbital tumor, metastasis to the eye and orbit)
relevant to specific clinical rotation(s) (eg, oculoplastics, cornea,
glaucoma, retina, ophthalmic oncology).**
4. Describe
and interpret reports of more advanced techniques in ophthalmic
histopathology (eg, cytology, special stains, transmission electron
microscopy, immunohistochemistry, tumor free margins) relevant to
specific clinical rotation(s) (eg, oculoplastics, cornea, glaucoma,
retina, ophthalmic oncology), including how the clinician
communicates the need for these studies.**
B. Technical/Surgical Skills
1. Process
appropriately more advanced specimens for submitting to an ophthalmic
pathology laboratory, including writing of the accompanying letter to
the ophthalmic pathologist (eg, impression cytology, fine needle
aspiration biopsy, vitreous biopsy, evisceration, exenteration
specimen).**
2. Perform
and submit a biopsy for frozen section study in ocular pathology.**
3.
Participate under supervision through a site visit in a macroscopic
and microscopic examination of ophthalmic specimens from active
cases, working from low to high power.
Advanced Level Goals: Year 2 and Year 3
These
goals relate to the second and third years of ophthalmic residency
training, for residents with a special interest in ophthalmic
pathology.
A. Cognitive Skills
1.
Describe less common ocular anatomy (eg, pars plana cysts), and
identify the histology of the minor structures (eg, ciliary sulcus)
of the eye and its adnexa relevant to specific clinical rotation(s)
(eg, oculoplastics, cornea, glaucoma, retina, ophthalmic oncology).**
2. Describe
the pathophysiology of less common disease processes of the eye (eg,
most common syndromes, less common corneal and retinal dystrophies
and degenerations and ocular neoplasms,
ocular lesions in acquired immune deficiency syndrome) relevant to
specific clinical rotation(s) (eg, oculoplastics, cornea, glaucoma,
retina, ophthalmic oncology),
and identify their major histologic findings.**
3. Describe
and interpret reports of advanced techniques in ophthalmic pathology
(eg, flow cytometry, molecular genetics) relevant to specific
clinical rotation(s) (eg, oculoplastics, cornea, glaucoma, retina,
ophthalmic oncology).**
B. Technical/Surgical Skills
1.
Participate as an “at-the-elbow” observer during microscopic
examination of active ophthalmology cases, including special
stains.**
2. Participate
in gross examination and cutting of common ophthalmic pathology
specimens (eg, eyelid biopsies, corneas, whole globes), and take
macroscopic and microscopic photographs to document pathologies.**
3.
Prepare a basic histologic specimen (eg, hematoxylin-eosin stain)
for review by the ophthalmic pathologist.
4.
Perform microscopic examination of a specimen under supervision, and
participate in writing the report, preferably previewing slides in
advance of the pathologist to come up with a diagnosis and to suggest
special stains and immunohistochemistry without the influence of the
ophthalmic pathologist, followed by reviewing the report and special
stain orders with the latter.
Very Advanced Level Goals: Subspecialist
These
goals relate to, but build upon and are more advanced and distinct
from, the second and third years of ophthalmic residency training.
A. Cognitive Skills
1. Describe
advanced ocular anatomy, and identify histology of the minor
structures of the eye and their uncommon variants (eg congenital
grouped pigmentation).**
2
Describe the more complex pathophysiology of the disease processes
of the eye, and identify major histologic findings of each (eg,
inflammatory pseudotumor, lymphoma, artifacts of tissue processing,
virus particles).**
3. Describe
the histology of the less common but potentially vision or
life-threatening ocular and adnexal diseases (eg, healed giant cell
arteritis, mimics and masqueraders of inflammation and neoplasm, less
common benign and malignant neoplasms).**
4. Describe
ancillary procedures for oncology (eg, bone marrow aspiration,
cerebrospinal fluid cytology).
B. Technical/Surgical Skills
1. Manage
consultation between the clinician and ophthalmic pathologist
regarding indications for special stains (eg, Gram stain for
bacteria, Congo red for amyloid; Gomori methenamine silver staining
for fungi; Prussian blue for hemosiderosis; von Kossa for calcium;
Oil Red O or Sudan Black for sebaceous carcinoma) or processing (eg,
orientation of specimen, special handling).**
2. Participate
as an observer during the microscopic examination of active
ophthalmology cases, including more advanced stains and techniques.**
3. Participate
in subspecialty clinical pathological meetings (eg, with corneal
surgeons, infection specialists, tumor board).**
4. Handle
appropriately gross or cytologic specimens in the ophthalmic
pathology laboratory (eg, vitreous biopsy, exenteration specimen).
5.
Prepare more advanced histologic specimens for review by the
ophthalmic pathologist (eg, special stains or fixation methods such
as glutaraldehyde fixation for electron microscopy).
6.
Perform microscopic examination of a paraffin-embedded specimen and
a frozen-section specimen without direct supervision; provide a
relevant differential diagnosis; draft a report–preferably
previewing slides in advance of the pathologist–to come up with a
diagnosis and to suggest special stains and immunohistochemistry,
without the influence of the ophthalmic pathologist; review the
report and special stain orders with the ophthalmic pathologist.
7. Participate
with the ophthalmic pathologist in tumor board and similar
multidisciplinary meetings, presentations on recent advances, and
journal clubs involving pathology.
8.
Research requirement: Publish at least one paper based on basic,
translational, or clinical research involving ophthalmic pathology.
The purpose of the requirement is to further the trainee’s in-depth
knowledge of pathophysiology and laboratory techniques relating to
ophthalmic pathology.
*
* *
Note: Inclusion
of therapies and investigations in the ICO Residency Curriculum does
not imply that listings are all inclusive or that methods are
endorsed by the ICO. Appropriate levels of expertise and knowledge
should be achieved based on the care provided. Practitioners should
know of therapies and investigations not available at their hospital
or clinic, so that they can advise patients who may be able to seek
care elsewhere.