ICO Subspecialty and Residency Curricula

Documents for Comment

ICO Residency Curriculum V. Refractive Surgery

Basic Level Goals: Year 1

 

A. Cognitive Skills
1. Describe simple types of refractive errors: **
a. Myopia
b. Hyperopia
c. Astigmatism
d. Presbyopia
2. Describe basic optic principles, such as line of sight and Purkinje image.**
3. Explain theories of accommodation.
4. Describe the basics of ophthalmic optics, including how the following affect the optics of the eye: **
a. Low and high order aberrations
b. Corneal layers
c. Shape of cornea
d. Shape of lens
5. Describe basic refraction techniques using trial lenses or phoropter for basic refractive errors, including:
a. Retinoscopy
b. Modification and refinement of subjective refraction
c. Cycloplegic retinoscopy and refraction
d. Postcycloplegic refraction
6. Describe the optical principles of common refractive surgery diagnostic tools, including:
a. Ultrasonic pachymetry
b. Keratometer
c. Lensometer
d. Pupillometry
e. Corneal topography
f. Scheimpflug imaging and elevation maps
g. Optical coherence tomography (OCT)
7. Describe the following topographic maps using different scales (ie, absolute, normalized, adjustable):
a. Axial
b. Instantaneous
c. Refractive
8. Describe normal corneal topographic patterns, as well as topographic signs of keratoconus and ectasia.
9. Describe elevation topography maps and their importance in screening refractive surgery candidates.
10. Describe indications and limitations of corneal topography in refractive surgery.
11. List the mandatory diagnostic tests necessary for refractive surgery.
12. Describe the basics of laser biophysics and laser tissue interaction.
13. Describe the complications of high myopia, high hyperopia, and pathologies related to high astigmatism.**

14. Define the clinical stages of keratoconus and forme fruste keratoconus using clinical and topographic tests.**
15. Describe the milestones in refractive surgery development, including radial keratotomy, keratomileusis, and phakic intraocular lenses (IOLs).
16. List current refractive procedures, their mechanisms of action, indications, and limitations, including:
a. Types of excimer laser procedures
b. Phakic IOLs
d. Implantation of intracorneal ring segments
e. Corneal inlays
f. Accommodative lenses
17. Describe the main IOL calculation formulas.
18. Describe the principles and different types (ie, linear, rotational, pendular) of mechanical microkeratomes, including their characteristics, indications, risks, and possible complications.
19. Describe the role of femtosecond technology in refractive surgery, including advantages and limitations of flap creation with a femtosecond laser.
20. Describe different techniques of keratoplasty and their relation with refractive surgery.

B. Technical/Surgical Skills

1. Perform objective and subjective refraction, including cross cylinder and Worth 4-dot test. **
2. Diagnose refractive defects.**
3. Use different prescription formulas.**
4. Prescribe spectacles for at least 20 patients with simple refractive errors (eg, myopia, hyperopia, regular astigmatism).**
5. Perform refraction on patients with extreme errors of refraction (eg, 5 patients with hyperopia over 8.0 D, and 5 patients with myopia above 20.0 D).**
6. Use the lensometer to measure spectacle power.**
7. Use the keratometer to make corneal measurements.**
8. Use the ultrasonic pachymeter to measure corneal thickness.
9. Validate corneal topography maps, including elevation topography. Recognize signs of ectatic disorders and/or candidates at risk for an unsatisfactory refractive surgery outcome, and rule out poor-quality tests (eg, artifacts, alignment, and corneal exposure issues).
10. Interpret an aberration map and evaluate its significance in the refractive defect of a patient, as well as the need to treat or not.
11. Validate a manual refraction as a real refractive defect of a patient, comparing results with keratometers, aberrometers, and topography.
12. Analyze tear film and tear deficiency.
13. Recognize and unmask astigmatism from higher order aberrations, such as coma.
14. Demonstrate how informed consent should be explained.

Standard Level Goals: Year 2


A. Cognitive Skills

1. Describe various types of refractive defects, and define the possible corrective solutions for each one.**
2. Describe basic diagnostic tools used in refractive surgery, including topography, pachymetry, and biometry; and interpret results.**
3. Describe more complex types of refractive errors, including postoperative refractive errors following cataract surgery, keratoplasty, refractive surgeries, ectatic conditions, and irregular astigmatism.**
4. Explain basics of wavefront analysis, including ray tracing and dynamic skiascopy, and graphical representation of wavefront errors, including corneal and entire eye high-order aberration maps, point-spread function, and modulation-transfer function.
5. Describe the basics of Zernike polynomials and Fourier analysis.
6. Use different topographic maps and scales for different purposes (eg, screening, postoperative evaluation, detection of complications).
7. Describe the basics of measuring contrast sensitivity.
8. Describe laser-tissue interaction and explain Munnerlyn formula.
9. Describe corneal biomechanics, including biomechanical responses to keratorefractive surgery, corneal healing after excimer laser procedures, corneal hysteresis, and corneal resistance factor.
10. Define and diagnose post laser in-situ keratomileusis (LASIK) ectasia, and differentiate it from other conditions.
11. Describe the mechanism of action, indications, advantages, and potential complications of mitomycin C application in surface ablation.
12. Describe the affect of corneal crosslinking on the biomechanical properties of the cornea, including its indications and how it can be combined with other refractive surgery procedures.

B. Technical/Surgical Skills

1. Perform refraction techniques using trial lenses or phoropter for basic and more complex cases, including:
a. Modification and refinement of subjective manifest refractive error
b. Cycloplegic retinoscopy and refraction
c. Postcycloplegic refraction
d. Contact lens use
e. Irregular astigmatism
f. Postkeratoplasty
g. Refractive surgery cases
2. Apply the basics of optics and optical principles of refraction and retinoscopy in the clinical setting, including higher order aberrations.
3. Gather accurate information essential for preoperative evaluation of patients seeking refractive surgery, including:
a. Medical interview
i. Patient expectation
ii. Social history
iii. Medical history
iv. Pertinent ocular history
b. Physical examination
i. Uncorrected visual acuity
ii. manifest and cycloplegic visual acuity
iii. Intraocular pressure
iv. Slit-lamp examination
v. Fundus examination
4. Diagnose and manage dry eye prior to surgery.
5. Use the keratometer to make corneal measurements in more complex patients (eg, prior corneal surgery or corneal disease), and correlate results with corneal topography maps, visual acuity, and quality of vision.
6. Use basic refractive instruments and techniques (eg, auto refractor, pachymetry, automated corneal topography, aberrometer, pupillometry, contact lens refraction, OCT, corneal hysteresis, and corneal resistance factor) in the clinical setting for refractive surgery patients.
7. Assist in developing patient care management plans for simple refractive errors (eg, myopia, hyperopia, regular astigmatism), and define the risks and benefits for each procedure.
8. Assist in various types of refractive surgery, including:
a. Twenty surface ablation procedures
b. Twenty LASIK procedures
c. Ten intracorneal ring segment implantation procedures
d. Ten phakic IOL surgeries

Advanced Level Goals: Year 3


A. Cognitive Skills

1. Describe and diagnose various types of refractive problems, including irregular astigmatism, and identify the best solution for each.**
2. Describe the most complex types of refractive errors, including postoperative refractive errors, postkeratoplasty, and refractive surgery.**
3. Describe the most advanced optics and optical principles of refraction and retinoscopy, including higher-order aberrations.
4. List the indications for and interpret preoperative and postoperative diagnostic testing, including:
a. Corneal topography
b. Wavefront analysis
c. Pachymetry
d. Calculation of stromal-bed thickness before and after LASIK
e. Aspheric profile of ablation
5. Formulate informed diagnostic and therapeutic decisions based on patient information, current scientific evidence, clinical judgment, and patient expectations.
6. Describe accommodative and nonaccommodative treatments of presbyopia, including:
a. Monovision
b. Excimer laser correction
c. Conductive keratoplasty
d. Corneal inlays
e. Accommodating IOLs
f. Multifocal IOLs
7. Describe the advanced formulas for IOL calculation in extreme myopia, hyperopia, and after corneal refractive surgery.
8. Develop patient care management plans for more complex cases (eg, mixed and irregular astigmatism, irregular corneas, combined refractive surgery procedures).
9. Describe the basics of modulation transfer function (MTF), point speed function (PSF), and Strehl ratio as objective ways to measure quality of vision.
10. Describe the basics of topography-guided, wavefront-guided, and optimized ablations as compared to standard ablations.

B. Technical/Surgical Skills

1. Perform basic refractive surgery procedures, such as low myopia or low hyperopia with LASIK (microkeratome) and surface ablation (LASIK or photorefractive keratectomy [PRK]).
2. Perform the most advanced objective and subjective refraction techniques using trial lenses or the phoropter, including:
a. Contact lens refraction for more complex refractive errors, including modification and refinement of subjective manifest refractive error
b. Cycloplegic retinoscopy and refraction
c. Postcycloplegic refraction
d. Irregular astigmatism
e. Postkeratoplasty
f. Refractive surgery cases
3. Utilize the most advanced optics and optical principles for refraction and retinoscopy, including higher order aberrations.
4. Utilize the keratometer for detection of subtle or complex advanced corneal refractive errors.**
5. Use and interpret results from more advanced refraction instruments and techniques (eg, corneal topography, pupillometry, aberrometry, Scheimpflug imaging, OCT).
6. Fit contact lenses in patients with irregular corneas, irregular astigmatism, and following refractive surgery.
7. Assist in advanced refractive surgeries, including topography-guided ablation, wavefront-guided ablation, and combined refractive surgeries.
8. Encourage patients to actively participate in their own care by providing disease and treatment information, and counsel patients on how to prevent postoperative injury.**
9. Correct refractive error after surgeries, such as penetrating keratoplasty, deep anterior lamellar keratoplasty, and radial keratotomy.

Very Advanced Level Goals: Subspecialist


A. Cognitive Skills

1. Diagnose and treat difficult cases such as irregular astigmatism.**
2. Identify and utilize the new technological advances in refractive surgery.**
3. Formulate informed diagnostic and therapeutic decisions based on patient information, current scientific evidence, and clinical judgment:
a. Use effective and appropriate clinical problem-solving skills
b. Understand the limits of one’s knowledge and expertise
c. Use consultants and referrals appropriately
4. Collect data, analyze refractive outcomes, and develop personal nomograms based on data.
5. Plan for retreatment of patients who had refractive surgery.
6. Develop refractive surgery management plans in the context of other conditions (eg, dry eyes, herpes, keratoconus, postkeratoplasty, glaucoma, retinal disease, amblyopia).
7. Describing methods of IOL calculation after refractive surgery.

B. Technical/Surgical Skills

1. Prescribe and perform procedures essential for the scope of practice.
2. Screen patients for refractive surgery.
3. Develop and carry out patient care management plans.
4. Perform the following, if feasible:
a. Twenty surface ablation procedures
b. Twenty LASIK procedures
c. Ten intracorneal ring segment implantation procedures
d. Ten phakic IOL surgeries
5. Perform under supervision 10 advanced refractive surgeries for complicated cases, including excimer laser enhancement procedures and topography-guided ablations for highly irregular corneas.
6. Perform–if feasible–supervised femtosecond refractive surgical procedures, specifically three femto-Lasik procedures and three intracorneal ring segment implantation procedures using a femtosecond laser.
7. Perform–if feasible–supervised corneal crosslinking on five eyes.

* * *
Note: Inclusion of therapies and investigations in the ICO Residency Curriculum does not imply that listings are all inclusive or that methods are endorsed by the ICO. Appropriate levels of expertise and knowledge should be achieved based on the care provided. Practitioners should know of therapies and investigations not available at their hospital or clinic, so that they can advise patients who may be able to seek care elsewhere.